Rossopomodoro in New York City

Rossopomodoro in New York City
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

200 5td Ave, New York City, NY 10010-3302, New York City

Overview

Cuisine
  • Italian
  • Pizza
Features
  • Takeout
  • Reservations
  • Seating
  • Waitstaff
  • Wheelchair Accessible
Good for
  • Kids
  • Families witd children

Restaurant Hours

Monday

9:00 am

Wednesday

9:00 am

Friday

9:00 am

Sunday

9:00 am

How good is the pizza

Very good! Try the truffle mushroom and the margherita - both are brilliant!

Do you have an outdoor space for dining?

There is a small outdoor dining area along the side of the building.

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Rossopomodoro
KB
Katie Boudreau
google
11.21.2024
4/5

A great spot for fresh Italian food. Our party had nothing but great things to say about the food here, everyone left happy and full.The Bolognese is delicious!! I cleaned my whole plate, and that's a rare thing for me! Can't wait to go back again.The only downside was service was on the slow side, but the staff was very accommodating and friendly.

Rossopomodoro
AH
Andrew H
google
09.19.2018
4/5

Wood burning oven pizza. Customized crusts (doneness), tasty toppings

Rossopomodoro
JS
Jairo Soto
google
08.13.2018
5/5

Pretty good and fast service. Great Margarita pizza.

Rossopomodoro
gg
giulio galante
google
08.07.2018
5/5

Real Italian Pizza. Probably the best in NYC

Rossopomodoro
GC
Gloria Cheng
google
06.05.2018
5/5

Had the margarita pizza. It’s amazing what freshly made tomato sauce and cheese can do for a pizza! Crust was perfect- right amount of salt, airiness, and texture.Service was impeccable- albeit a bit slow.

Rossopomodoro
BB
BRYANN BRICKELL
google
06.04.2018
5/5

Spectacular. Service food atmosphere, all delicious! Definitely will be back.

Rossopomodoro
BM
Brian Michalski
google
05.25.2018
5/5

I was pleasantly surprised by the food and service here. It's reasonably priced but very good Italian food. I'll be back

Rossopomodoro
tf
the f in the chat
google
05.23.2018
5/5

Great food! Service was great as well.

Rossopomodoro
PR
Pete R
google
05.19.2018
5/5

Excellent food with friendly service.I highly recommend this West Village gem.

Rossopomodoro
AB
Allyson Berger
google
04.10.2018
5/5

An absolutely delicious local favorite!The food is incredible and tastes like it’s straight from Grandma’s kitchen. A great date spot or just for going out with friends. The ambiance is amazing. Staff is super friendly, personable and professional. You’ll want to keep coming back time after time.

Rossopomodoro
SS
Steve S
google
02.06.2018
5/5

Gluten free pizza bliss!!! This place must be the first place you visit. Popular with the locals and for a good reason, the service and the food!

Rossopomodoro
CW
Christopher Wolstenholme
google
01.23.2018
5/5

I love this place, amazing food in a city that has so many options, I visit here everytime I come to NYC.

Rossopomodoro
EL
Erin L
google
11.23.2017
5/5

We came with a group of 4 and everyone loved what we got! We came before dinner to have a drink at the bar - bar tender was friendly and helped us select a bottle of wine. Dinner was phenomenal - my husband and I are gluten free and they had many options and everything was delicious.

Rossopomodoro
M(
MaryJo (MJ) Pham
google
10.21.2017
5/5

Sublime, from the superb management and welcome -- to the incredible dough fired up on the pizza. The sauce, the cheeses, I almost don't want to share this review lest more people know! Unmistakably delicious.

Rossopomodoro
HL
Hannah Lee
google
10.14.2017
4/5

Great spot for pizza and pasta! The staff is friendly and everything on the menu looks fantastic. Came on a reservation but there is a bar so you can always have a seat there or hang out before being seated

Rossopomodoro
WC
William Capone
google
09.18.2017
4/5

I was so very sorry to read on the Rossopomodoro restaurant web-site that they were closing permanently as of July 31st. I had many really great meals there and it is tragic due to the pandemic that they have become one of its victims. It is a great loss to the neighborhood and beyond.

Rossopomodoro
MM
Megan Maxim
google
09.11.2017
5/5

Rossopomodoro was definitely the best way to start and end my New York trip! The capriciossa pizza is the best pizza that I have ever had in the US. The dough is soft and chewy, and it tastes like an authentic Neopolitan pizza! The tomato sauce is delicious, and I love how it is sweet and not salty. In addition, the pizzas are loaded with toppings, and they are all fresh, high quality ingredients. The service is also phenomenal, and all of the staff were very personable and treated us like family. Thank you Rossopomodoro for one of the best dining experiences I have ever had, and I look forward to returning here the next time I come to New York.

Rossopomodoro
PA
Polly Anywhere
google
07.24.2017
1/5

This rating, wish it could be no star, was for the service tonight. We were seated, with no water, no service for a LONG time. Water poured in, no one asked for our preference. No one came to tell if any specials; and no one took our orders for a LONG time when neighboring table who sat later than us were all getting their drinks. Appetizer took a long time; the pastas were over 35 min ... and no apology. When asked for spoons to enjoy the pasta sauce with, the server threw the spoons ... I could not hold longer and went to complained to the manager, no apology. It seems that they were doing us a favor by opening the extra room (we had reservation) ... no apology for anything. SO I thanked the manager for ruining our night ... asked for the bill; he finally came and said no bill tonight. Whatever. It's all too late. It's sad. Would not come back again; too many other yummy choices with better attitudes.

Rossopomodoro
CM
Carla McSpadden
google
07.20.2017
5/5

We had a large group for a special occasion but Rossopomodoro staff were so helpful in planning and making everything great this evening! The food was amazing! Our entire group was over the moon about the quality of the food and wine. It was one of the best Italian meals we’ve ever had. And the customer service exceeded our expectations! Thanks for making our evening special.

Rossopomodoro
AM
Angelica McHuston
google
07.04.2017
5/5

I am obsessed. This was an impeccable meal. We started with the FARROW AND SQUASH SALAD, it has an amazing balance and interesting flavor, it wasn’t heavy. Then the NEAPOLITANO PASTA WITH ITALIAN SUSAGE- it was divine. We did add a little red pepper. Finally the CHICKEN ENTREE was flawless and incredible. We are definitely coming back. $81 for two: 2 drinks 2 apps 1 entree

Rossopomodoro
JS
Jennifer Silverman
google
06.27.2017
4/5

Have been before- and loved it so much we returned. One dish we ordered this time was very very salty.. however my husband does not like to return meals...he just ate it. ( Linguini with clams) Otherwise all was delicious..fast service!

Rossopomodoro
JM
James Mirro
google
06.22.2017
5/5

Excellent food. Pizza, pasta and much more. An outstanding Italian restaurant. Highly recommend.

Rossopomodoro
PB
Paolo Bucciol
google
06.18.2017
5/5

Pretty good pizza. Not as thin as Neapolitan pizzas in the middle (style resembles more Northern Italian pizza), but definitely one of the top 3 I’ve had in the States so far. Ingredients are OK. Cheese was a bit greasy. Limited pizza menu, not many options for red pizzas.

Rossopomodoro
AR
Aishwarya Ramje
google
06.13.2017
1/5

I didn’t have a good time at this place. The food was okay, chicken a little dry. I used to love this place, and I am sad to say the service was sub par yesterday. The waiter seemed rude and didn’t really care if we had a good time. The only thing that was good was that we got water served on the table. But everything else was kinda off, it took forever to get the drinks. I’m really sad. This was my go to place.

Rossopomodoro
JS
Joshua South
google
05.23.2017
5/5

It took a lot of “chutzpah” for Rossopomodoro to invade New York. Any New Yorker will assure you that New York Pizza is the world’s best. According to New Yorkers, even the local neighborhood hole-in-the-wall pizza joint serves reheated slices of pizza heaven. Rossopomodoro takes pride in hand-crafting every individual pizza from the freshest, healthiest, organic, and most expensive ingredients. Without criticizing New York generic pizza, Rossopomodoro is indeed special, well worth the premium price.

Rossopomodoro
Dt
Demons to Diamonds
google
04.23.2017
5/5

Adorable wee spot, fun patio on the side walk in lovely neighborhood. Can confirm gluten free pizza is on point. Crust is light, crispy and tasty. I had the mushroom truffle pizza and the ingredients were fresh, flavorful and generous. Service was super warm, attentive and personable. I would go back!

Rossopomodoro
JL
Josh Lewis
google
04.01.2017
5/5

We came here after seeing it on Worth It on YouTube. We really enjoyed the pizza, the crust is something else entirely. It's got little burnt spots which provide some bitterness, but the sauce cuts through it and provides a really great flavor. Definitely worth a trip.

Rossopomodoro
AB
Alexander Benjamin
google
02.15.2017
5/5

They are incredible now with making reservations and so accommodating when you want to change them. Incredible food! The tagliatelle bolognese and short rib ragu are my favorite!

Rossopomodoro
Meghan
google
02.10.2017
5/5

Cozy Italian spot with amazing gluten free pizza and pasta options. The service is always great. A must try in NYC.

Rossopomodoro
LGR
google
02.07.2017
3/5

They really dropped the ball!Came in at noon, we were the only customers in the place. Winter weather outside, and no heat inside. We ordered two of their $30 pizzas. They came to the table hardly warm. We sent them back to be reheated, and they brought us back two new pies. That was a nice try. However, neither of them were hot either.Their food is delicious. But it needs to be hot when it reaches the table. Which really wasn’t that far of a walk, so I don’t understand how that could have happened. But it was a big disappointment. We did not have enough time left to send it back for the second time. Unlikely I will return.Our server, Stephanie, took our one beer and one bottle of sparkling water off the bill. Apparently, that was the most the manager would allow her to deduct. Thank you, Stephanie, you tried hard to save the game for your team. It’s too bad that your manager was so determined to stumble.

Rossopomodoro
LR
Liliana Rozum
google
01.20.2017
3/5

Amateur service:1. We asked if there is a fresh orange juice, the answer was positive so we ordered - we got definitely not a fresh one.2. Tap water was refilled in my glass even though I asked for sparking one.3. Waiters unwillingly do the serviceReally nice decoration, but extremely loud inside in the restaurant.Delicious food, portions could have been a bit bigger.

Rossopomodoro
WG
Wade Guenther
google
11.21.2016
4/5

Rossopommodoro has very good food! The orecchiette and ravioli were amazing. The truffle and mushroom pizza was also really good. We havent had the truffle pizza in many locations.The atmosphere was really nice. It's a small, intimate, spot with a great location.Our service was questionable. Our server simply forgot our drink orders in more than two occasions. Otherwise, great food and good experience.

Rossopomodoro
Ac
Antoine couture
google
10.26.2016
5/5

Amazing service ambiance and food

Rossopomodoro
DK
Daniel Kassell
google
10.21.2016
4/5

Good GlutenFree Pizza bit needs to be crisped on the bottom.

Rossopomodoro
LD
Lauren DeMaio
google
09.23.2016
3/5

Pizzas were unimpressive as were first course items. Pasta was well made. Our server was under trained but her support staff seemed to know what's up.

Rossopomodoro
AC
Angelo Cirillo
google
09.06.2016
5/5

Nice food, pricey but well worth!

Rossopomodoro
GB
Giovanni Botta
google
08.27.2016
4/5

Very good food. The octopus was cooked perfectly. The pizza was delicious. All the appetizers we tried were amazing, particularly the burrata.

Rossopomodoro
BM
Benjamin Millar
google
08.16.2016
4/5

Very attentive staff at this Italian restaurant. Separate wine menu but there are other drinks, incl beer & cocktails, on the main menu. They had the dogfish IPA which I tried. Got a selection of starters to try. The prosciutto & the caprese salad were memorable. They had specials which included the 'tomahawk' - a 24oz piece of beef to share. There was also a whole red snapper to share. They'd run out of the tomahawk so I got the NY strip and it was damn tasty, very tender & lightly salted. There were tasty sounding options for dessert but I was too full.

Rossopomodoro
SC
Sarah Cohen
google
08.09.2016
5/5

Great food. Great service. Sat on time for our Rsvp. Were not rushed. Rigatoni was epic. Toffee caramel dessert = must have. Will be back!

Rossopomodoro
Ci
Cheryl inAction
google
08.05.2016
4/5

Charming place in the West Village. Gluten Free pizza & pasta options. Always a plus.

Rossopomodoro
MB
Marcus Boerger
google
06.26.2016
5/5

I came in very late and they immediately gave me a menu but still gave me time to consider my order. I ended up ordering Salami Pizza and a glass of Barolo. Both turned out to be fantastic and work together very well. All in all the atmosphere was nice, the stuff were all very friendly and food and drinks great. So I went on and suggested this place already to colleagues.

Rossopomodoro
AA
Alessandra Alari
google
05.18.2016
5/5

I know this can be difficult to admit by our American friends but pizza was born in Naples. If you say that this pizza is not cooked, sorry, but you don't know what pizza is. I know Rossopomodoro from Italy, and the NYC branch didn't disappointed. My pizza with mushrooms and truffle was great!

Rossopomodoro
EM
Edward Madory
google
05.18.2016
4/5

The waiter was very likable and gave us excellent service. The minestrone soup was served hot and tasty. The French toast was very good, especially the bread. The mimosa used fresh orange juice and the bloody Mary was very spicy. However the stairs down to the restrooms were steep and worn.

Rossopomodoro
LV
L V
google
05.09.2016
1/5

Poor pizza. Ordered 2 pizzas while on a date and we could even finish 2 slices. Honestly tasted undercooked and sloppy. Picked up a single slice and all the toppings + cheese slid right off. Wouldn’t waste 28 dollars on a pizza from here.

Rossopomodoro
KS
K Sun
google
03.16.2016
4/5

Pizza might have been better if hot. But gf pizza dough was pretty legit

Rossopomodoro
IU
Indu Unnamatla
google
02.26.2016
4/5

Good food and service.

Rossopomodoro
LT
Leslie Teng
google
02.07.2016
5/5

Attentive service. Really good food. Pastas have a good bite to them. Chocolate marchesa is a particularly good dessert.

Rossopomodoro
it
iraida torres
google
01.15.2016
4/5

The food is fresh and delicious, service is good and the staff is nice and pleasant. Pasta portions are a bit on the small side but always yummy.

Rossopomodoro
YL
YouJin Lee
google
01.09.2016
4/5

Lunch special deal was pretty good Full size portion of salad and a little bit smaller portion of entree

Rossopomodoro
Walter
google
01.04.2016
2/5

Came here cause someone famous on Instagram posted a picture of the pizza. It was such a disappointment. The lobster pasta was too spicy and the pizza was soggy. Like literally soggy. Everything came apart once you lifted the pizza off the dish.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 12122292560

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!